Minutes of the Annual Meeting
May 10, 2007
Call to Order
President Roger Hirschland called the meeting to order at 7:10 pm
at the Washington Marriott Hotel, 1221 22nd St., N.W. on May 10, 2007.
Proof of Notice of Meeting
Attendees acknowledged the disbursement of the meeting notification
Attendance
Present were Board Members President Roger Hirschland, Treasurer
Joseph Morris, Secretary Elizabeth VanderPutten, Vice President Dwight
Clark, Vice President John Filice and a sufficient number of owners in
person or represented by proxy (45.2610%) to constitute a quorum. Also
present at the meeting were Property Manager Walter Krolman; legal
counsel Joe Douglass from the firm of Whiteford, Taylor, Preston; and
Larry Simmons, president of the Simmons Management Group.
Reading of Minutes
Reading of the 2006 Annual Meeting Minutes was waived by consent of
Membership
President's Report
After introducing his fellow board members and describing the
financial condition of the Lauren as sound, President Hirschland
introduced and thanked Messrs. Krolman, Douglass, and Simmons, and
then discussed major activities of the board during the 2006/07 year.
Financial Management - The board chose to
change our financial management firm this year from Koger to Simmons.
The board had been concerned about communication, reporting, and
difficulties getting the 2005 audit. After selecting the new firm, the
board learned from reports in the Washington Post, as did other
condominiums, that there were serious problems with Koger. Although
some condominiums appear to have lost funds, there is little evidence
we have seen that the Lauren has suffered financially: The board is
pleased with our new financial management firm, the Simmons Management
Group.
HVAC - The President discussed the situation of the HVAC
system. The board appointed a committee of Brian Larkin, Dwight Clark,
and John Filice. Based on previous surveys and studies, it is clear
that the HVAC Whalen units need to be replaced. The committee reviewed
several options and concluded that the most cost effective approach
was to replace the current system with a similar system. The board did
not want to have to levy a special assessment now or in the future or
to borrow the $2 million for the HVAC replacement. They asked owner
and former board member Brian Larkin, an economist, to develop a plan
that could pay for the replacement by increasing condo fees and
spreading payments over a period of years. In order to extend the life
of the current units, the board arranged for the sealing of
condensation pans in the current units, which has been accomplished.
Starting with the 2007 budget, a special HVAC reserve account has been
established. This will allow the Lauren to replace the units when
necessary necessary-in an estimated six to seven years-without having
to collect a special assessment or to totally deplete the reserves
below $500,000 at any time.
Tax Issues - There have been some D.C. tax issues that needed
to be resolved, including lost payments and payments credited to other
accounts. Only $1,200 remains to be resolved, and the manager is in
communication with the D.C. tax office regarding the matter.
Emergency Preparedness - The President reminded the owners of
the PEPCO transformer failure outside the building in February. Since
then, the Lauren has acquired additional flashlights so that if this
were to happen again, at least there would be sufficient light for
people returning to the building to reach their units. The President
reminded owners that it is their responsibility to have appropriate
emergency supplies inside their own units.
Water Valve Replacements - The President discussed the need to
replace two sets of water valves in the building. The main valves to
the building were corroded and could no longer be totally closed. In
addition, many of the 17 riser valves that control water in each tier
could not be completely closed and needed to be replaced. Since these
valves are located inside owners' units on the 10th floor, the board
opted to move them at the same time into the hallways where they are
always accessible in emergencies. Appropriate notice will be given to
owners and residents about impending water shut-offs, as was done when
the main valve was replaced.
Redecoration - The President reported that a redecoration
committee has been working under the direction of Erin Erlenborn, and
includes Barrett Witkin, Dwight Clark, John Filice, and Roger
Hirschland. The charge is to develop a plan to update the hallways and
elevators within a reasonable budget. The last time the hallways were
redone was 1996.
Other Business - The board is conducting a study of how best to
replace the boiler to increase efficiency and effectiveness. The
bicycle cage has been repaired. There is now upgraded security
equipment, including a new camera on the lower level. This will also
help the Lauren identify persons who leave discarded heavy equipment
or furniture, so it can be removed at the expense of the owner, rather
than of the Lauren.
Kudos - The President thanked Nathalie Peter for originally
helping to start the Lauren recycling program. In addition to helping
to protect the environment, the program has resulted in a significant
decrease in trash and the cost of trash pickup. He thanked David
Lilling for continuing to spur activity that has resulted in the soda
machine working in the laundry room, and Deborah Becker for organizing
the clothing drive during the holidays, to which many residents and
owners contributed items. The President thanked Brian Larkin for his
continued work with the Lauren Web page.
Treasurer's Report
Audit
We expected to have the final 2005 audit available for distribution
at this meeting, but at the last minute, our auditor informed us that
he was missing a necessary balance confirmation statement from one of
the banks in which we have CDs, so the audit has not been finalized.
We believe it will be completed momentarily; the new board will
distribute it as soon as it is available. Because of the problems with
unsatisfactory record keeping by our previous management company, the
2006 audit will be delayed for some months. We do not yet have an
estimate from our auditor of when the 2006 audit will be delivered.
Analysis
The graphs distributed summarize the history of the finances of the
association. These are updates of the graphs handed out at last year's
meeting. The dollar amounts are from the annual audited statements
through 2004. 2005 data are from the 2005 draft audit and 2006 data
are from the December monthly statement from the financial management
company.
The first graph shows the history of operating expenses since 1990.
The three components are labor costs, utilities, and everything else.
The second graph shows annual percentage increases in total
operating expenses, labor, and utilities. Most noteworthy are the
increases in utilities in the past several years: up 11 percent in
2004, 9 percent in 2005, and 14 percent in 2006. The 2007 budget
anticipates a small decline in utilities from last year because of
reduced gas rates. Total operating expenses are rising faster than
inflation-it took 10 years for the Lauren's operating expenses to grow
from $500,000 to $600,000, four years to go from $600,000 to $700,000,
and just 2 years from $700,000 to $800,000.
2006 was a relatively slow year for capital expenditures (third
graph), about $60,000 for various improvements, replacements and
engineering studies. The President has described possible upcoming
capital expenditures.
The fourth graph shows how the association has been preparing for
needed capital expenditures. The graph, labeled "net cash,"
shows the sum of all our bank account and CD balances, less all
amounts currently owed to employees and outside parties. In other
words, we could pay all our current bills and have this amount left
over. This measure excludes the association's other principal asset
(in addition to bank accounts and CDs), which is the Lauren apartment
we own.
As the President explained, starting this year we have accelerated
contributions to the capital reserve because we anticipate the need to
replace all of the in-unit heating and air conditioning equipment from
approximately 2013 to 2015. This will be the largest capital project
ever undertaken by the association. For planning purposes, we are
assuming an expenditure of $2 million over three years.
The bottom graph on the right (to a different scale than the one
beside it) shows the plan that the outgoing board developed for paying
the HVAC replacement. It will be up to each future board to decide
each year whether to stick to this plan. The plan calls for increasing
the rate of annual contributions to the reserve fund to build up a
fund approaching 2 million dollars in five years, and then drawing
down the fund to pay for the HVAC.
Higher contributions to reserves must be paid for with higher
condominium fees. In 2006, the contribution to the reserve fund (not
including interest) was equal to 16 percent of condominium fee
revenue. In 2007, this ratio will be 21 percent and, according to the
plan developed by the board, in 2016 the reserve contribution will
equal 28 percent of condominium fee revenue.
The graph does not show it, but, to help us monitor progress toward
paying for the HVAC, the board has begun to keep track of the capital
reserve as two separate accounts, the normal reserve, and the HVAC
reserve. The 2007 budget and the monthly treasurer's report at board
meetings show the totals in each of these two accounts.
Other Board Member's Report
Board member Elizabeth VanderPutten thanked Roger Hirschland for
his leadership this year, which she described as filled with thorny
issues that ran the gauntlet from personnel management to boilers to
HVAC financing. She said she particularly appreciated his calm and
steady hand.
Reports of Committees
Decorating Committee - Erin Erlenborn
reported on the status and early work of the redecorating committee.
Two design companies have met with the committee. The goal is to have
modern, long-lasting hallways and elevators. Some new materials are
much more durable, such as bleach-proof carpeting and stainless steel
fixtures. The previous cost of redoing the hallways was about $90,000
in the mid 1990s.
Election of the Board
A Board of Electors was voted on. Members were John Chester,
Nathalie Peter, and David Tulchinsky.
Election Results
Four serving board members were nominated. In addition, Jeffrey
Wertkin was nominated. The nominees were elected by acclamation. The
2007-2008 Board of Directors is:
· Roger Hirschland
· Jeffrey Wertkin
· Elizabeth VanderPutten
· Dwight Clark
· John Filice
Other Discussion
Tobacco Smoking as an Irritant in the Building
President Roger Hirschland opened a discussion about smoking inside
apartments. The board has received a number of complaints. There are
some floors where a number of persons smoke in their apartment and the
smoke leaks into adjoining units and the hallways. Minutes of board
meetings have reported on this topic.
Some owners, he reported, have suggested that the entire building
become smoke free, but that would mean telling people what they cannot
do in their own units. According to the Lauren attorney, there are
some legal precedents for this and some condominiums have implemented
such policies. If the Lauren were to do this, it would probably
grandfather current owners who smoke. Our legal counsel advises that
it would be best to change the bylaws, rather than having just the
board make the policy by decree. Changing the bylaws to prohibit all
smoking would require approval by 80 percent of the ownership.
One question dealt with the potential impact on property values,
noting that the effect of a nonsmoking policy could be positive or
negative. Mr. Hirschland responded that one possible comparison is
that of the effect on bars and restaurants in D.C., which became smoke
free January 2, 2007. The experience has been generally positive. He
also noted that restaurants in California and New York have reported
increases in sales since going smoke free. Most of those present
expressed agreement. Brian Larkin, who maintains the Lauren Web site,
reported that almost all owners who advertise their units for rent
include no-smoking notices.
Enforcement is another issue. Are there penalties? How do you
handle reporting? Joe Douglass pointed out that there are always
people who will violate rules. The kinds of sanctions include possible
fines or injunctive relief. That is one reason why the grandfathering
of current owners and residents is recommended. The Lauren has in
several cases attempted to seal air leaks in affected units, including
the use of foam, and installing smoke filters inside smokers' units.
No remedy has been successful.
One suggestion was to do a survey of the entire ownership before
going through the full process of amendment. Another suggestion was to
talk with realtors about their perspective. The President asked for a
nonbinding vote to gauge interest in pursuing the matter. Approval for
looking into the matter for further action was almost unanimous.
D.C. Property Assessments - Nathalie Peter asked whether others had
appealed their assessment. Efficiencies appear to have been assessed
higher than the selling prices. No other owners indicated that they
had appealed the assessments.
Adjournment
The annual meeting was adjourned at 8:30 pm
Respectfully submitted,
Elizabeth A. VanderPutten, Secretary
TO SUBSCRIBE
To receive e-mail copies of Board Minutes, send a request to
Property Manager Walter Krolman at manager@lauren.org
Minutes and other Lauren information may be found in the Business
Section of the Lauren Web site www.lauren.org/business.htm
|